Hello dear
Welcome To Sexton’s Pizza
Sexton’s Pizza, located at 5460 Franklin St in Hilliard, OH, is a culinary gem celebrating the art of pizza-making with a focus on unique, customizable creations. Known for its New York-style 16-inch pies and expertly crafted Motown deep-dish offerings, this vibrant eatery prides itself on delivering fresh, flavorful experiences. The signature wood-fired crust boasts the perfect blend of char and crunch, reminiscent of the best pizzerias. With a delightful selection of sauces and mouthwatering cupcakes to complement your meal, Sexton’s Pizza fosters a welcoming atmosphere where every visit feels special. Come savor the deliciousness that has locals raving!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Build Your Own Pizza
Mikes Hot Honey Bottle
Specialty 12” Cauliflower
BBQ
About
Sexton’s Pizza
Welcome to Sexton’s Pizza, a gem nestled in Hilliard, Ohio, at 5460 Franklin St. If you’re a pizza aficionado, prepare to embark on a culinary adventure that celebrates the art of wood-fired pizza. With an array of specialty pies that elevate classic recipes, Sexton’s promises a delightful experience for every palate.
What sets *Sexton’s Pizza* apart? It starts with their dedication to quality ingredients. For instance, the Margherita Pizza features fresh sliced mozzarella, a touch of olive oil, sea salt, and fragrant basil, all beautifully melding together for $24.20. If you’re a fan of pepperoni, don’t miss the East Village Pepperoni—an owner favorite that showcases the unbeatable combination of crisp Ezzo pepperoni atop a bed of creamy mozzarella and fresh basil for just $23.50.
For those seeking something unique, the Hakuna Ricotta pizza, adorned with Ezzo sausage crumble and whipped ricotta, is a must-try, priced at $24.00. Meanwhile, the Kevin Bacon offers an indulgent twist with candied bacon and pepperoni for $23.50, making it a flavorful option for those with adventurous taste buds.
Beyond traditional dough, health-conscious diners can relish the 12" Cauliflower Crust, available for $14.75 as a build-your-own option or as a specialty pie for $17.50. This signature crust is light yet satisfying, perfect for gluten-sensitive guests without compromising on flavor.
Sexton’s doesn’t stop at pizza; their dessert offerings are equally compelling. Treat yourself to cupcakes such as Chocolate Peanut Butter or Birthday Cake, each priced at $5.50. These sweet additions wonderfully complement the savory pies, making your visit a complete experience.
- Customer Praise: Patrons consistently highlight the lightweight, crispy crust and excellent taste. Keli Young notes, “The wood-fired crust had a delightful char, making it one of the best I’ve experienced.”
- Tim Adzic appreciates the polite service and the great ratio of sauce, cheese, and toppings, solidifying Sexton’s as a top contender in the Columbus pizza scene.
- Joe Walton, a loyal takeout customer, claims it’s the closest to NY-style pizza he’s found locally, expressing hope that they maintain their quality as they expand.
The atmosphere is another highlight, with friendly staff attentive to your dining experience. Nichole Armstrong noted the food is always served hot and fresh, contributing to the inviting feel of the restaurant. Dillyn Dorsey remarked on the great music and impeccable service, enhancing the overall ambiance.
In conclusion, whether you’re enjoying a casual lunch or a family dinner, Sexton’s Pizza promises an exceptional culinary experience. The combination of fresh ingredients, creative toppings, and a warm atmosphere makes this pizzeria a must-visit. Indulge in the flavors of Sexton’s Pizza—you won’t be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Had lunch here, and we really liked it- we got 2pizzas- the 614 and one with basil and mozzarella. It is wood fired pizza, so some of the crusty bits were well done- but that comes with most of that type of pizza I’ve had. (And they were big- we each took home 5-6 pieces) ”
“ This is some of the best pizza in the Columbus area. Great taste and awesome crust. If you love a lightweight, crispy crust pizza, then you will love this. The inside is also great and the wait staff was very polite. ”
“ I have only done takeout but I have ordered here four times. This is by far my favorite pizza in Columbus. The crust has just the right amount of char and crunch. Closest to NY style pizza that I’ve had in Columbus. I am very happy they are expanding to another location in Lewis Center. I hope they continue to make great pizzas and not cut corners because they have a great pizza here. ”
“ Had a wonderful time at this location, last night was my first visit and will not be my last. This pizza is so good, I love pizza that the crust is not floppy. I got the NY style dairy air and it was one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time. The music was great, the service was great, the food was impeccable and I can’t wait to go back! ”
“ The staff is friendly and attentive. Food came out hot and fresh. The pizza is delicious. It's cooked well and has a great ratio of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The only thing I'm not the biggest fan of is the paper products, especially the silverware to help cut it up for kids. ”
“ The best naturally flavored pizza crust I've had. The pizza as a whole is phenomenal. Crispy not greasy, pepperonis are great, sauce flavored well. Good drinks! Fun place to go and is pretty busy. Next time I'll get a photo, because this post deserves a photo. ”
“ The pizza was absolutely amazing. Super crispy with the perfect amount of sauce, cheese and pepperoni. If I lived here I’d be here 3-4 times per week for sure. Drinks were delicious too!! ”
“ Listen, this was probably the best pizza we've ever had. It was charred perfectly, with a lightness to it that made it so unique. Then you get this burst of flavor. We ordered a "Mike" NY style and a "Kevin Bacon" Motown style. This deep dish motown style was my absolute favorite. The salad was vig enough for three people to share. And the garlic parm fries were delish. Great atmosphere here too. Get there early as they do sell out of pizza. ”